There are sins we commit, sins we encourage, sins we ignore, and sins we simply allow to continue.
The first two are easy to recognize. The last two trouble me more because they rarely introduce themselves as sin. They often arrive wearing respectable names: patience, compassion, tolerance, loyalty, even love.
Scripture has an uncomfortable way of exposing them.
I keep returning to Eli.
His sons, Hophni and Phinehas, had corrupted the priesthood. They abused their position, treated the sacrifices of Israel with contempt, and behaved as though proximity to holy things somehow excused unholy lives.
Eli knew. He even confronted them. But knowing and speaking were not enough.
God said to him:
“Wherefore kick ye at my sacrifice and at mine offering, which I have commanded in my habitation; and honourest thy sons above me, to make yourselves fat with the chiefest of all the offerings of Israel my people?”
— 1 Samuel 2:29, KJV
Later the judgment becomes even clearer:
“For I have told him that I will judge his house for ever for the iniquity which he knoweth; because his sons made themselves vile, and he restrained them not.”
— 1 Samuel 3:13, KJV
That last part stays with me: he restrained them not.
Eli was not accused of committing their sins. He was judged for knowing what they were doing while failing to exercise the responsibility that was still his.
There is a point where correction without consequence begins to resemble permission.
And nowhere is that danger greater than within a family.
We can often see another person’s child behaving badly and call the behaviour exactly what it is. When it is our own child, explanations begin to appear. He is still young. She is going through something. They will grow out of it. I do not want to push them away. I do not want my child thinking I do not love them.
These are not always dishonest excuses. Sometimes they come from real tenderness. A parent suffers when a child suffers.
But I think this is also one of the ways children become spoilt.
Not because they were loved too much, but because love became protection from truth.
A parent keeps removing consequences because watching the child suffer is painful. The child slowly learns that someone will always soften reality on his behalf. Then eventually he enters a world that does not love him enough to do that.
Perhaps part of parental love is preparing a child to meet a world that will not love him like a parent does.
That thought leads me to Samuel.
Something struck me while reading this story that I had somehow never really stopped to consider before.
Samuel was essentially raised under Eli.
Hannah was his mother, of course, and Scripture never erases her role. But she dedicated Samuel to the Lord while he was still a child, and from then on he lived and ministered under Eli:
“And Elkanah went to Ramah to his house. And the child did minister unto the LORD before Eli the priest.”
— 1 Samuel 2:11, KJV
That creates one of the strangest ironies in the story.
How could Eli do so much with someone else’s son and so poorly with his own?
Samuel grew into one of Israel’s greatest prophets. He learned to hear God. He judged Israel. He confronted kings. He anointed Saul and David. He became almost everything Hophni and Phinehas were not.
And Eli had helped raise him.
Maybe this tells us something uncomfortable about family relationships. Distance sometimes gives us clarity. It is easier to insist on standards when the person before us does not carry our blood, our guilt, our memories and our fear of losing them.
With our own children, everything becomes more complicated.
But then Scripture turns the knife again.
Samuel grew old. He appointed his sons as judges. And then we read:
“And his sons walked not in his ways, but turned aside after lucre, and took bribes, and perverted judgment.”
— 1 Samuel 8:3, KJV
The boy raised under Eli had escaped the corruption of Eli’s sons. Yet his own sons did not walk in his ways.
I do not think Scripture gives us enough information to say that Samuel failed in exactly the same way Eli did. Eli is explicitly condemned for failing to restrain his sons. Scripture does not give Samuel the same judgment.
But that does not make the comparison meaningless.
As a Christian, I believe Scripture can provoke questions beyond what is explicitly stated. The Holy Spirit can use even what appears to be silence in the text to force us to examine ourselves. What I should resist is turning reflection into certainty where Scripture itself has not done so.
So I am left thinking about the paradox.
Samuel could stand before Saul and tell a king that God had rejected him, yet somewhere within his own household were sons who took bribes and perverted justice.
Perhaps that should humble every parent, pastor, teacher and leader.
You can teach someone. You can correct them. You can model something better. You can pray for them. You can even sacrifice for them. And still, eventually, they must choose.
This is where I have to resist an easy conclusion. Eli’s story could tempt us to think that every failure of a child proves a failure of the parent. Samuel’s story complicates that idea.
Parents carry responsibility, but they do not possess another person’s will.
There is such a thing as permissiveness, but there is also such a thing as control disguised as righteousness. A parent can spoil a child by refusing to correct him, but a parent can also damage a child by trying to control every decision, every thought and every mistake.
So parental responsibility cannot mean producing a certain outcome at all costs. It means being faithful to the responsibility one actually has.
Israel eventually looked at Samuel’s sons and concluded that the system itself had failed.
They told Samuel:
“And said unto him, Behold, thou art old, and thy sons walk not in thy ways: now make us a king to judge us like all the nations.”
— 1 Samuel 8:5, KJV
Their complaint was legitimate. Samuel’s sons really were corrupt.
But a correct diagnosis does not guarantee a correct solution.
Israel had seen priests fail. Now judges had failed. Their answer was political: give us a king.
God’s answer went deeper:
“And the LORD said unto Samuel, Hearken unto the voice of the people in all that they say unto thee: for they have not rejected thee, but they have rejected me, that I should not reign over them.”
— 1 Samuel 8:7, KJV
Israel believed another structure might solve what was fundamentally a problem of the human heart.
We still do this.
When governments fail, we redesign governments. When churches fail, we start new churches. When organizations fail, we restructure them. When families struggle, we search for another parenting philosophy, another method, another system.
Sometimes structures genuinely need to change. Bad systems can encourage bad behaviour, and good systems can restrain it.
But no system can manufacture virtue.
Israel eventually received its kings. Saul failed. David achieved greatness and committed terrible sins. Solomon possessed extraordinary wisdom and still compromised himself. Eventually the kingdom itself divided.
The system changed, but the human heart remained.
Centuries later, Christ speaks to the church in Thyatira. He first acknowledges what is good:
“I know thy works, and charity, and service, and faith, and thy patience, and thy works; and the last to be more than the first.”
— Revelation 2:19, KJV
Then immediately:
“Notwithstanding I have a few things against thee, because thou sufferest that woman Jezebel, which calleth herself a prophetess, to teach and to seduce my servants to commit fornication, and to eat things sacrificed unto idols.”
— Revelation 2:20, KJV
That passage brings me back to Eli. The church had love. It had faith. It had service. It had patience. And it still tolerated something Christ said should not have been tolerated.
That is where I think the balance lies.
Love is not the same thing as perpetual correction. There are moments when love should be patient, moments when it should forgive, and moments when someone must be allowed to make a mistake and bear responsibility for it.
But love cannot require us to rename what we know is destructive simply because telling the truth might damage the relationship.
Nor does responsibility mean ownership.
A parent can guide a child without owning the child’s conscience. A pastor can teach without controlling every member. A friend can warn without becoming judge and jailer.
At some point another person’s decision becomes their own.
That does not erase our responsibility. It defines its limits.
Eli could not make Hophni and Phinehas righteous. Samuel could not make his sons righteous. God Himself did not remove Israel’s ability to reject Him.
That alone should cure us of the fantasy that sufficient control can produce virtue.
But Eli’s story should cure us of the opposite fantasy too: that love excuses us from confronting what we are responsible for.
That is where I finally land.
I do not believe every silence is cowardice. Sometimes silence is patience. Sometimes it is wisdom. Sometimes a person needs room to learn what our words cannot teach.
But when I know something is destroying someone entrusted to my care, when I still carry some responsibility toward them, and when the main reason I refuse to act is that I fear losing their approval, then I should at least question what I am calling love.
Maybe the most dangerous form of love is the one that protects a relationship while allowing the person inside it to deteriorate.
Eli loved his sons. I do not doubt that. But Scripture still says:
“Thou… honourest thy sons above me.”
And perhaps that is the warning.
Love must be willing to suffer misunderstanding in order to remain truthful.
Otherwise, eventually, silence becomes permission.
— Faraja Majaliwa

Leave a Reply